Thursday March 18th, 2010    Home  |   Topics  |   Most Popular  |   Media Bookings  |   About Us  |   Contact Us  |   Book Store  |   Support
Search & Archives
 
View All Authors
View All Topics
RSS 2.0 Feed
Atom 0.3 Feed
Font Size
[+] Increase
[−] Decrease
Reset
Receive PM in
daily digest form

subscribe
unsubscribe


Must-Read Columnists
Mitch Albom
Michael Barone
Dave Barry
Tony Blankley
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Greg Crosby
John Fund
Frank J. Gaffney
Jonah Goldberg
Jonathan Gurwitz
Victor Davis Hanson
Nat Hentoff
Jeff Jacoby
Paul Johnson
Ch. Krauthammer
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Bill O'Reilly
Clarence Page
Dennis Prager
Wesley Pruden
Jonathan Rauch
Cokie & Steve Roberts
Debra J. Saunders
Thomas Sowell
Mark Steyn
John Stossel
Cal Thomas
Bob Tyrrell
Diana West
George Will
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman
Cartoonists
Chuck Asay
Chip Bok
Dry Bones
Gary Brookins
Prickly City
John Cole
Cox & Forkum
J. D. Crowe
John Deering
Mallard Fillmore
Jake Fuller
Ed Gamble
Bob Gorrell
Joe Heller
Steve Kelley
Jeff Koterba
Doug Marlette
Michael Ramirez
Jeff Stahler
Wayne Stayskal
Gary Varvel
Monthly Archives
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006


Fairness, empathy and Sotomayor
By Mark Davis (bio)

  • Tell a Friend
  • Printer Friendly
  • Font [+]
  • Font [–]

We’ve all seen it in Supreme Court confirmation hearings: Conservative senators bristle at liberal nominees; liberal senators bristle at conservative nominees.

The difference? Conservatives lament liberal appointees’ tendency to depart from the Constitution’s language. Liberals lament the conservatives’ tendency to cleave to it.

Case in point: Democratic Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse accused Republicans of looking for a nominee to bring about their desired political results. Talk about the New England crackpot calling the kettle black.

The conservative view, on matters from abortion to gay rights, is to let the Constitution’s actual 10th Amendment to rule the day, allowing the states to fashion their own laws on how much life to protect in the womb and how much homosexual marriage to legally recognize.

In the various states, conservatives obviously will fight to protect the unborn and the historic definition of marriage, an enormous departure from the modern judicial fabrication of a national “right” to end prenatal life or “right” to have gay marriages viewed as the equal to heterosexual unions.

Neither are rights. They are things some constituencies want passionately, and they should be debated in the states.

It is the left that seeks to mandate its worldview by judicial fiat, a legacy of whims too often based not on law but on social wish lists.

Sonia Sotomayor repeatedly expressed her view that a “wise Latina,” by virtue of her outlook, is a better judge than a white man. If that is not racism, the word has no meaning.

She sought to deny white and Hispanic firefighters their deserved promotions in a Connecticut case because black aspirants did not pass the test. This is racism punctuated by activism. All of this is an instant disqualifier for the highest court in the land.

Much has been made of “empathy,” an instinct that is a vital part of human kindness but a complete irrelevancy to the law.

Whitehouse, the Democrat from Rhode Island, sought lamely Monday to bolster the absurdity of the empathy argument: “The courtroom can be the only sanctuary for the little guy,” he pined, “when the forces of society and elected officialdom will lend him no ear.”

What utter nonsense. In a million cases that come before the Supreme Court, the “little guy” often will be on the side of the law, but sometimes not. A big, despised corporation or the big, nasty government often will be wrong, but sometimes not.

The job of a judge is to be as blind to whom is before the court as the statue of Lady Justice, blindfolded with her scales held aloft to weigh only – only! – the merits of the case before her.

But Sotomayor, in speeches and rulings, has shown a habit of pulling down that metaphoric blindfold to see who is before her, in order to gauge what she thinks of them before ruling.

“Empathy for one party is always prejudice against another,” proclaimed ranking Republican Sen. Jeff Sessions of Alabama, nine words that cut with clarity to disembowel the most artful posings of those who view the Supreme Court as some empowered leveler of our national playing field.

The sports analogy is useful: In the recent NBA finals, the referees could have called ticky-tack fouls against the oft-crowned champion Los Angeles Lakers against the upstart Orlando Magic, a team the officials could have aided by turning their heads when they broke the rules.

The righteous public revulsion at such an outrage should be the same reaction when a judge subjugates the law to some self-created storyline of “fairness.”

The only judicial fairness is found in impartiality, an attribute Sotomayor may claim all week. But she has sufficiently abandoned it to such a degree that only one question remains: Which Republicans will realize that neither political correctness, nor energized Hispanic voters, nor their own self-preservation instincts are as important as protecting the Constitution from this nominee?

Digg this

Have PoliticalMavens.com delivered to your inbox in a daily digest by clicking here

Posted by Mark Davis on July 14th, 2009
Permanent link: Fairness, empathy and Sotomayor
PM Fellows
Dan Ackman
Arnold Ahlert
Robert Alt
Sheryl J. Anderson
Jeff Andrus
Bob Asahina
Thomas Fox Averill
Gerard Baker
Jeff Ballabon
Anne Bayefsky
Arnold Beichman
Ralph Kinney Bennett
Claire Berlinski
Brendan Bernhard
William Beutler
Chip Bok
Jerry Bowyer
Joe Bob Briggs
Peter Brookes
Frank Buckley
Dennis Byrne
Colleen Carroll Campbell
Amb. Richard Carlson
Charles Robert Carner
Ron Cass
Jim Ceaser
Lauren Chapin
Lionel Chetwynd
Ron Christie
Andrew Colarik
Phil Cooke
Seth Cropsey
Greg Crosby
Stanley Crouch
Monica Crowley
Gordon Cucullu
Keith Curtis
Lee Casey & David B. Rivkin, Jr.
Mark Davis
Sam Dealey
Brad Dickson
Alan W. Dowd
Political Mavens Editor
Paul Eidelberg
Steven Emerson
Tucker Eskew
Amitai Etzioni
Karen Feld
Robert Ferrigno
Danny Fontana
Peter Fox
Cory Franklin
Ilana Freedman
Will Friedwald
Doug Gamble
Daveed Gartenstein-Ross
Jeff Gedmin
Robert A. George
Dan Gerstein
George Gilder
Benjamin Ginsberg
Malibu Rules Girl
Mark Goffman
John Steele Gordon
Julia Gorin
Lloyd M. Green
Paul Greenberg
Cynthia Grenier
Jennifer Grossman
Judy Gruen
Allen C. Guelzo
Michel Gurfinkiel
Jonathan Gurwitz
Dennis Hale
Karen Hall
Eldon L. Ham
Earl Hamner
Matthew P. Harrington
Aaron Keith Harris
Betsy Hart
Sam Haskell, III
Jacob Heilbrunn
Mark Hemingway
David Henderson
Scott Hennen
Amb. G. Philip Hughes
John Hughes
Patrick Hurley
Blake Hurst
Susan Isaacs
Donovan Jacobs
Dallas Jenkins
Marianne Jennings
Bridget Johnson
Melodie Johnson Howe
Brian C. Jones
Mark Joseph
Mark Judge
Stefan Kanfer
Jeff Katz
William Katz
Jonathan Kay
Jack Kelly
Paul Kengor
Larry Kenny
Andrew Klavan
Judith A. Klinghoffer
Elizabeth Koch
Eugene Kontorovich
Dave Kopel
Elie D. Krakowski
Michael Krauss
Josh Larsen
Leslie S. Lebl
Norman Lebrecht
Michael LeGault
Eli Lehrer
Allan Leicht
Michael Levine
Nathan Lewin
Amy Linker
Herbert London
Mike Long
Laura Lorson
Douglas MacKinnon
Harvey Mansfield
Stephen Mansfield
Rich Markey
Josh Marquis
Dana Marshall
Craig Mazin
David McFadzean
John Meroney
Herbert E. Meyer
Richard Miniter
Howard Mortman
Gerald Nachman
Noam Neusner
Anna Nimouse
Cyrus Nowrasteh
sambo
Mackubin Owens
Kathleen Parker
Marilyn Penn
David D. Perlmutter
Phil Perrier
Peary Perry
Eric Peters
Paul Petersen
Walid Phares
Lisa Pinto
Everett Piper
John J. Pitney,Jr.
Steve Pomerantz
Steve Pressfield
Arch Puddington
Jeremy Rabkin
Rachel Raskin-Zrihen
David Reinhard
Lisa Reitman-Dobi
Richard Riordan
Heather Robinson
Dave Rosner
Evan Sayet
Felice Schachter
Abby Wisse Schachter
Richard Schifter
William Schmidt
Sam Schulman
Sherwood and Lloyd Schwartz
Peter Schweizer
Todd Seavey
Jeremy Shane
Neal M. Sher
Dave Shiflett
Marvin Silbermintz
Max Singer
Curt Smith
Scott Stantis
Steve Stark
Harry Stein
Neil Steinberg
The Stiletto
Glenn Sulmasy
Joel Surnow
Seth Swirsky
Steven L. Taylor
Keith Thibodeaux
Bruce Thornton
Kelly Jane Torrance
Prof. Bob Turner
Cynthia Vance
Laura Vanderkam
Chris Warren
Ben Wattenberg
Ken Weinstein
Barry Weiss
Gary Weiss
Claudia Wells
Diana West
Christine B. Whelan
John O Whitaker Jr
Kaitlyn Wilkins
William Wintersole
Kate Wright
Meyrav Wurmser
Toby Young
Bryce Zabel
Robert Zelnick
John Ziegler
Spread Political Mavens
yahoo
myaol
mymsn
rojo
google
sub-bloglines
sub-feedster
newsgator
newsburst
pluck
delicious
furlit
searchfox
jrants
 
Home  |  Advertise  |  Privacy Policy  |  Subscribe

Copyright (c) 2006 POLITICAL MAVENS. All Rights Reserved.