Tuesday May 22nd, 2012    Home  |   Topics  |   Most Popular  |   Media Bookings  |   About Us  |   Contact Us  |   Book Store  |   Support
Search & Archives
 
View All Authors
View All Topics
RSS 2.0 Feed
Atom 0.3 Feed
Font Size
[+] Increase
[−] Decrease
Reset
Receive PM in
daily digest form

subscribe
unsubscribe


Must-Read Columnists
Mitch Albom
Michael Barone
Dave Barry
Tony Blankley
Mona Charen
Linda Chavez
Greg Crosby
John Fund
Frank J. Gaffney
Jonah Goldberg
Jonathan Gurwitz
Victor Davis Hanson
Nat Hentoff
Jeff Jacoby
Paul Johnson
Ch. Krauthammer
David Limbaugh
Michelle Malkin
Bill O'Reilly
Clarence Page
Dennis Prager
Wesley Pruden
Jonathan Rauch
Cokie & Steve Roberts
Debra J. Saunders
Thomas Sowell
Mark Steyn
John Stossel
Cal Thomas
Bob Tyrrell
Diana West
George Will
Walter Williams
Mort Zuckerman
Cartoonists
Chuck Asay
Chip Bok
Dry Bones
Gary Brookins
Prickly City
John Cole
Cox & Forkum
J. D. Crowe
John Deering
Mallard Fillmore
Jake Fuller
Ed Gamble
Bob Gorrell
Joe Heller
Steve Kelley
Jeff Koterba
Doug Marlette
Michael Ramirez
Jeff Stahler
Wayne Stayskal
Gary Varvel
Monthly Archives
May 2012
April 2012
March 2012
February 2012
January 2012
December 2011
November 2011
October 2011
September 2011
August 2011
July 2011
June 2011
May 2011
April 2011
March 2011
February 2011
January 2011
December 2010
November 2010
October 2010
September 2010
August 2010
July 2010
June 2010
May 2010
April 2010
March 2010
February 2010
January 2010
December 2009
November 2009
October 2009
September 2009
August 2009
July 2009
June 2009
May 2009
April 2009
March 2009
February 2009
January 2009
December 2008
November 2008
October 2008
September 2008
August 2008
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
January 2007
December 2006
November 2006
October 2006
September 2006
August 2006


Encyclopedias to Revise Word for “Serb”
By Julia Gorin (bio)

  • Tell a Friend
  • Printer Friendly
  • Font [+]
  • Font [–]

Apparently, there’s no such thing as a Serb. From reading English-language media, there are only things called “Serbnationalists” or “Serbiannationalists”. And there is no such place as Serbia, only Serbianationalism. Just look at this “article” from the L.A. Times about the Serbian [sic] version of the reality show “Big Brother”. It’s titled “Turning a Lens on Serbian Nationalism”, but I can’t find any examples of Serbian nationalism in the article. Maybe someone else can read it and tell me where the nationalism is, or else confirm that there’s no such thing as a Serb, only a Serbnationalist:

Turning a lens on Serbian nationalism

The country’s version of ‘Big Brother’ includes the odd Bosnian, Croat and Kosovo Serb. Probably unintentionally, it’s forcing viewers to confront their social prejudices.

By Tracy Wilkinson, Los Angeles Times Staff Writer

BELGRADE, SERBIA — It didn’t take long for voters to eject Burek from the house in Serbia’s version of the “Big Brother” reality TV show.

A Serb from the distant (and disputed) province of Kosovo, Burek was clearly seen as a country bumpkin. He ate hot dogs and pickles for breakfast, he crassly tried to hit on women in the house, and his bathroom habits were, well, a little on the rudimentary side.

“Everything about him stinks of primitivism,” one viewer wrote in a long-running Internet chat room that focused on the show — and particularly on Burek, whose real name is Zivan Janicijevic and whose nickname is the word for a greasy cheese pastry.

So much for “Only Unity Can Save the Serbs,” the battle cry of Serbian nationalists for generations: Burek, by popular vote, was unceremoniously evicted a few weeks into the program.

Was that the nationalism?

And then there was Elmir Kuduzovic: of all things, a Bosnian Muslim, who joined the housemates shortly before Burek was ousted. Elmir, it turns out, was something of a hit. Good-looking and macho, he got rave reviews.

“Women adore him,” one fan wrote. “You can see he’s cool. A little rough around the edges, but a true man.”

A Muslim being a hit in Serbia. Is that the nationalism they’re talking about?

In rejecting fellow Serb Burek and maintaining Muslim Elmir, the viewers of this Belgrade-produced television program were drawn somewhat tentatively into a debate about national identity and social prejudice.

The program managed (probably inadvertently) to bring exposure to issues, such as the lives of Kosovo Serbs, that do not normally penetrate mass culture in today’s truncated, dispirited Serbia.

(Ultimately, the show ended abruptly and tragically when the popular Elmir and two former housemates were killed in a car wreck just days before the winner was to be chosen. The three were traveling along icy roads to a big year-end party that got its cachet from having “celebrities” from the show in attendance.)

Serbia is all that remains of what was once Yugoslavia; the other Yugoslav republics, including Bosnia-Herzegovina and Croatia, split off to become their own countries following devastating civil wars; and Kosovo, where Serbian forces in 1999 fought ethnic Albanians backed by NATO, is expected to bolt soon as well. Even tiny Montenegro has seceded.

Is that the Serbian nationalism?

Dragan Ilic, a psychologist who serves as a commentator on “Big Brother” for the B-92 network that broadcasts it, said the show forces viewers to confront uncomfortable realities.

“It exposes the worst in people — that’s why it’s good,” Ilic said. “It opened us to problems of society, a lot of prejudices, even political problems, although politics are not allowed.”

That’s one of the rules: no politics. But politics creep in.

The setup of “Serbian Big Brother” (”Veliki Brat”) is identical to the versions aired in dozens of other countries: Contestants are confined to a house, given tasks, provoked into doing ridiculous things, all for the hope of money and a bit of fame.

Ilic said the producers’ decision to include the odd Bosnian, Croat and Montenegrin as housemates was not a gesture of altruistic brotherhood but a business decision. The producers wanted to appeal to viewers throughout the former Yugoslavia, where the program is also sold and broadcast.

Officials from the Emotion Co., which produces “Big Brother,” declined requests for an interview.

The success of the wildly popular show is in presenting the housemates without ideological or cultural baggage, “above reality,” said sociologist Zorica Tomic, the host of a top-rated talk show.

“It’s a kind of bonding . . . that we don’t have in the real world,” Tomic said.

The show even spawned a Romeo-and-Juliet-style romance in its first season last year, between Edin, a Muslim from the Bosnian capital, Sarajevo; and Maja, a Serb from the Serbian city of Nis. It didn’t last; they couldn’t agree on which country to live in.

Well Edin probably wanted to live in Bosnia, since he’s a Muslim and Muslims like to live in Muslim countries, or turn the non-Muslim countries they live in into Muslim countries, and Maja probably wants to put off being Muslim until Western policymakers make it a law for the entire region in a few years. So she obviously wanted to stay in Serbia. Is that the nationalism everyone’s talking about?

But no contestant has generated as much debate and mostly snarly criticism as Burek, 26, a high school graduate with heavy eyebrows, slightly buck teeth and an unshaven mug.

“Now I can see what Serbia is reduced to,” a viewer named Misha wrote. “They brought a peasant into the house. Terrible!”

“Such a simple man,” wrote another. “The prejudices about people from Kosovo prove to be true — their intelligence is quite low.”

So, so far Serbianationalism can be defined as self-loathing and self-betrayal. I’m starting to catch on.

But Burek also had defenders, people who gave him credit for at least being “natural.” “Just because he’s from a village in Kosovo, that’s nothing to be ashamed of,” said a viewer calling himself Jeddah. And: “You can’t draw conclusions about all Kosovo Serbs from one Burek.”

As that debate raged, Burek and Elmir, the Bosnian Muslim, tangled on the air. Elmir teased Burek about his real first name, Zivan, asking if it was common “among Albanians.” Ethnic Albanians are the overwhelmingly dominant group in Kosovo, dwarfing a community of Kosovo Serbs such as Burek, and are demanding independence. It was quite an insult.

Is that the Serbianationalism again? Even the Bosnian Muslim is keenly familiar with the Serbianationalism in which Albanians have cleansed 450,000 Serbs over the years and are taking the land. Here’s what that Serbianationalism looks like, for those who may have missed the brilliant piece that these visuals and captions accompanied:


Ruins of a Christian church in Kosovo blown up by Muslim Albanian urban planners after it was deemed unsuitable for conversion to a mosque.


A team of Albanian interior decorators evaluate the scope of work at the freshly ruined St. George Cathedral. (As usual, Serbian nationalists claimed they were a “Muslim mob looting and reveling in the ruins.”)


Albanian interior decorators take a break from redecorating 14th century churches to participate in a planning conference and receive instructions from the boss.


UN peacekeeper inspects improvements made to 14th century Serbian Monastery by Muslim architects of Kosovo.


British peacekeepers protect one of the few remaining churches in Kosovo from Albanian architects.

Now back to the article:

Burek retorted that Kosovo will always be Serbian. He looked ready to throw a few punches, before cooler heads prevailed.

Ilic, the psychologist, said ordinary Serbs had learned more about their Kosovo brethren in a few months of “Serbian Big Brother” than in years of political rhetoric, especially when television cameras traveled to Burek’s hometown and interviewed his neighbors. Although Serbs, almost universally, hail Kosovo as the medieval cradle of their religion and culture, few have actually spent time there.

“For the average Serb, a Kosovo Serb is like a dodo bird,” Ilic said. “This is the first time the life of common Kosovo Serbs was visible to the wider Serb audience.”

What the Los Angeles Times is telling you here is that there’s no reason to hold on to Kosovo, since most Serbs haven’t even seen it. But as Bill Dorich writes in an unpublished letter to the L.A. Times:

How often has [reporter] Tracy Wilkinson visited the Alamo? How many Americans have visited Pearl Harbor or the site of the World Trade Center? Does that make these historical sites less important to Americans? Your…Balkan journalist criticizes the Serbs who have never visited Kosovo, [but] that does not make Kosovo less of the cradle of Serbian religion where 1,500 Serbian churches have been built in the past 1,000 years.
…
Who is the next victim of your bigoted proclivities once the Serbs have been eradicated? Apparently cleansing 450,000 Serbs from Kosovo and destroying 151 ancient Serbian churches in the past 5 years has nothing to do with “Greater Albanian” nationalism?

Back to the article:

Eventually, Burek’s rube charm wore thin, and his enemies grew. Especially as he boasted of a masculine prowess not at all in evidence. “Girls are fired up for me, like a microwave,” he preened before the omnipresent cameras.

Burek got the boot early in the season. But he also got a bit of vindication: Under a rule that allows viewers to reinstate an evicted housemate, Burek was brought back a couple of weeks ago. To the astonishment of many.

Astonishment? Of many of whom? Serbianationalists?

Incidentally, when media report on the Croatian rocker who sings jolly tunes about concentration camps and war criminals, Marko “Thompson” Perkovic, they dutifully print his defense against accusations of fascist sympathies thus: it is nothing more than his proud Croatian nationalism.

So is nationalism a good thing…unless it’s Serbian?

Digg this

Have PoliticalMavens.com delivered to your inbox in a daily digest by clicking here

Posted by Julia Gorin on January 17th, 2008
Permanent link: Encyclopedias to Revise Word for “Serb”
PM Fellows
Dan Ackman
Arnold Ahlert
Robert Alt
Sheryl J. Anderson
Jeff Andrus
Bob Asahina
Thomas Fox Averill
Gerard Baker
Jeff Ballabon
Anne Bayefsky
Arnold Beichman
Ralph Kinney Bennett
Claire Berlinski
Brendan Bernhard
William Beutler
Chip Bok
Jerry Bowyer
Joe Bob Briggs
Peter Brookes
Frank Buckley
Dennis Byrne
Colleen Carroll Campbell
Amb. Richard Carlson
Charles Robert Carner
Ron Cass
Jim Ceaser
Lauren Chapin
Lionel Chetwynd
Ron Christie
Andrew Colarik
Phil Cooke
Seth Cropsey
Greg Crosby
Stanley Crouch
Monica Crowley
Gordon Cucullu
Keith Curtis
Lee Casey & David B. Rivkin, Jr.
Mark Davis
Sam Dealey
Brad Dickson
Alan W. Dowd
Political Mavens Editor
Paul Eidelberg
Steven Emerson
Tucker Eskew
Amitai Etzioni
Karen Feld
Robert Ferrigno
Danny Fontana
Peter Fox
Cory Franklin
Ilana Freedman
Will Friedwald
Doug Gamble
Daveed Gartenstein-Ross
Jeff Gedmin
Robert A. George
Dan Gerstein
George Gilder
Benjamin Ginsberg
Malibu Rules Girl
Mark Goffman
John Steele Gordon
Julia Gorin
Lloyd M. Green
Paul Greenberg
Cynthia Grenier
Jennifer Grossman
Judy Gruen
Allen C. Guelzo
Michel Gurfinkiel
Jonathan Gurwitz
Dennis Hale
Karen Hall
Eldon L. Ham
Earl Hamner
Matthew P. Harrington
Aaron Keith Harris
Betsy Hart
Sam Haskell, III
Jacob Heilbrunn
Mark Hemingway
David Henderson
Scott Hennen
Amb. G. Philip Hughes
John Hughes
Patrick Hurley
Blake Hurst
Susan Isaacs
Donovan Jacobs
Dallas Jenkins
Marianne Jennings
Bridget Johnson
Melodie Johnson Howe
Brian C. Jones
Mark Joseph
Mark Judge
Stefan Kanfer
S. T. Karnick
Jeff Katz
William Katz
Jonathan Kay
Terry Kelhawk
Jack Kelly
Paul Kengor
Larry Kenny
Andrew Klavan
Judith A. Klinghoffer
Elizabeth Koch
Eugene Kontorovich
Dave Kopel
Elie D. Krakowski
Michael Krauss
Josh Larsen
Leslie S. Lebl
Norman Lebrecht
Michael LeGault
Eli Lehrer
Allan Leicht
Michael Levine
Nathan Lewin
Phil Liberatore
Amy Linker
Herbert London
Mike Long
Laura Lorson
Douglas MacKinnon
Harvey Mansfield
Stephen Mansfield
Rich Markey
Josh Marquis
Dana Marshall
Craig Mazin
David McFadzean
John Meroney
Herbert E. Meyer
Richard Miniter
Howard Mortman
Gerald Nachman
Noam Neusner
Anna Nimouse
Cyrus Nowrasteh
sambo
Mackubin Owens
Kathleen Parker
Marilyn Penn
David D. Perlmutter
Phil Perrier
Peary Perry
Eric Peters
Paul Petersen
Walid Phares
Lisa Pinto
Everett Piper
John J. Pitney,Jr.
Steve Pomerantz
Steve Pressfield
Arch Puddington
Jeremy Rabkin
Rachel Raskin-Zrihen
David Reinhard
Lisa Reitman-Dobi
Richard Riordan
Heather Robinson
Dave Rosner
Evan Sayet
Felice Schachter
Abby Wisse Schachter
Richard Schifter
William Schmidt
Sam Schulman
Sherwood and Lloyd Schwartz
Peter Schweizer
Todd Seavey
Jeremy Shane
Neal M. Sher
Dave Shiflett
Marvin Silbermintz
Max Singer
Curt Smith
Scott Stantis
Steve Stark
Harry Stein
Neil Steinberg
The Stiletto
Glenn Sulmasy
Joel Surnow
Seth Swirsky
Steven L. Taylor
Keith Thibodeaux
Bruce Thornton
Kelly Jane Torrance
Prof. Bob Turner
Cynthia Vance
Laura Vanderkam
Chris Warren
Ben Wattenberg
Ken Weinstein
Barry Weiss
Gary Weiss
Claudia Wells
Diana West
Christine B. Whelan
John O Whitaker Jr
Kaitlyn Wilkins
William Wintersole
Kate Wright
Meyrav Wurmser
Toby Young
Bryce Zabel
Robert Zelnick
John Ziegler
Spread Political Mavens
yahoo
myaol
mymsn
rojo
google
sub-bloglines
sub-feedster
newsgator
newsburst
pluck
delicious
furlit
searchfox
jrants
 
Home  |  Advertise  |  Privacy Policy  |  Subscribe

Copyright (c) 2006 POLITICAL MAVENS. All Rights Reserved.